House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 Recap

Everything has been leading up to House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8, “The Treasons at Tumbleton.” Over the course of eight episodes, this season has been slowly inching toward the fight and fallout of the siege. But while we get the former in Episode 8, we don’t see much of the latter. 

With King’s Landing falling apart around Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen (Emma D’Arcy), Lord Ormund Hightower (James Norton) secured Tumbleton as his own and the temporary seat of power for his nephew, the newly named King Daeron Targaryen (Benjamin Evan Ainsworth), whom he announced to the Realm as King. The consequences of their bad decisions surround every character. The chaos of the power struggle has never been better on display than in House of the Dragon Season 3. 

A tragedy first, House of the Dragon Season 3 has doubled down on ensuring that every major character, in one way or another, has been racing to their own bottom. This has ultimately resulted in a story that doesn’t do much to endear characters from either the Blacks or the Greens; instead, it’s made the audience pity them. It’s a race to their respective bottoms. Well, except for King Aegon II Targaryen (Tom Glynn-Carney), who has somehow emerged with his dragon, Sunfyre, still alive. 

It’s this last bit that opens up House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8. As the season finale, “The Treasons at Tumbleton” wastes no time showcasing the fear that Sunfyre’s resurrection strikes in the heart of the Red Keep. On the verge of a panic attack, Rhaenyra enters Daemon’s room. As she hyperventilates, she announces the return of Sunfyre, and of Aegon, and Daemon (Matt Smith) can’t believe a single stitch of it. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 is the end of a very long road to Tumbleton.

But it’s not just their survival that makes this moment carry weight. It’s that Sunfyre’s restorative sleep was mistaken for death, and everyone who passed her as she slept saw the beast seemingly decaying on the forest floor. And Aegon, Rhaenyra, and his own mother have announced his death to the world, to the Realm, only for him to rise as well. 

As Rhaenyra says, the Smallfolk see this as divine. And while Rhaenyra can win support over a disgraced King who has run his city into the ground, does she have the strength to win out against a sign from the gods?

This compounds with the Sept’s refusal to officially coronate her upon the taking of King’s Landing, and her claim to the Iron Throne has been whittled away. A crack that formed just because she was a daughter and not a son has been pried open by Ormund Hightower’s announcement of King Daeron Targaryen and now blasted into a cavern by Aegon’s return to life. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 shows Rhaenyra at her lowest point. While the past two seasons built her up into a woman ready to rule as a king, the loss of her children, the hole that Aegon left, and her dwindling support have cast her as a ruler completely and utterly overwhelmed. She’s been paralyzed by cruel decisions. And while she rejects the weight of the crown, it continues to crush her.

Prince Daemon Targaryen, on the other hand, meets his wife with a softness that shows that he understands her fear, but still with a sternness that puts the blood of Old Valyria above anything else in the Realm. To him, she has the dragons and the promise of legend.

But to Rhaenyra, Viserys’ assertion of the prophecy has left her battered and broken. She has been tested time and time again, but now, she doesn’t know if she can pull through. 

The question for the audience in the opening moment of House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 is whether Rhaenyra’s crash-out consumes her, or if it gives her the push to do what she needs to. Which is to burn Tumbleton, to embrace the dragons, and rule with fire and blood. 

There is a moment in the episode’s opening where you question what Rhaenyra will do. And then, the camera pans in tight on her face as the panic leaves, the resolve fortifies, and she turns to her husband and gives him the command to attack Tumbleton. Hugh is to protect the Dragon Pit with Vermithor, and every single Hightower is to be killed. 

Baela Targaryen deserved more than what this bloated script handed her.

This is a moment we have waited for for much of Season 3. But it arrives nearly too late. The entire season has revolved around Tumbleton and how far Rhaenyra will go in trying to rule in peace. She has looked weaker and weaker with each episode, and in “The Treasons at Tumbleton,” she finally decides to become a monster, as foreshadowed earlier in the season.

She wanted to kill Aegon herself. She wants to kill Ormund and Daeron, the child she stressed about even touching just episodes ago. This is a vengeful Queen who has shaken loose her ideals and is choosing to allow the crown to mold her into the monster she promised not to be. When your back is against the wall, why not be cruel?

But lighting Tumbleton ablaze also means sacrificing Lord Corlys Velaryon (Steve Toussaint), and it’s something that Princess Baela Targaryen (Bethany Antonia) will not abide. House of the Dragon Season 3 has been an unmasking of the Queen.

Baela Targaryen isn’t Rhaenyra’s true daughter. Instead of bowing to her stepmother, she pushes back. While Rhaenyra is fine with letting Corlys die in the blaze, Baela wants to save him. And when Rhaenyra denies her that small kindness, Baela doesn’t hold back. 

It’s one of the few moments in the series where Baela has been allowed to speak as her own person. When she does, she points out how Rhaenyra dehumanizes everyone around her. She uses them while they’re useful, wielding them like tools. But when they’re not, she casts them away. It’s here where the reality of Rhaenyra’s selfishness comes to a head. The crown isn’t transforming Rhaenyra; it’s revealing her. 

The Rhaenyra that responds to Baela is one that we haven’t seen. House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 has unmasked her. Her true self leaps at the screen as she grabs Baela’s face and utters the words “insolent child” with disdain dripping from her lips. There is no one to root for in this series, except for the people kept underfoot of those fighting for a power that none of them truly deserve. 

Now, every road leads to Tumbleton. When the Driftmark soldiers arrive, they assume they will be used in Tumbleton to rescue their Lord Corlys. Instead, Alyn of Hull (Abubakar Salim) tells the soldiers that they are there to secure King’s Landing. When Alyn tells them to put Velaryon’s honor above fear, he also reveals to them that he is the future Lord of the Tides, the Seasnake’s eldest living son. 

In Tumbleton, the city is readying for war. The Smallfolk are being brought into the city’s walls. The Hightower army is preparing for a siege. Inside the main keep, Ser Ormund Hightower (James Norton) knights his nephew, Daeron Targaryen, and the words echo through the episode.

There is no honor on Ormund’s lips as he asks Daeron to take his oath. And there is no honor from the treason happening in the tavern as Ser Ulf the White (Tom Bennett) drinks and shares what he sees as the tale of Rhaenyra’s downfall. As he spreads his hatred of the Targaryens in the tavern, Rhaenyra is requesting an escort to the Sept to force the Maesters’ hands and make her Queen of the Realm. 

Heleana Targaryen may have looked to be the frailest of characters, but in this episode, her strength is seen. 

Despite her calm, everything that Rhaenyra is doing feels manic. She pulls Ser Alyn to make an entrance into the Sept that she knows will be unwelcome. She dismisses Mysaria (Sonoya Mizuno) and sends the White Worm to Pentos (which we can assume is to protect her from the coming battle). To add insult to injury, the Queen does so with one of her servants delivering the news to a woman she clearly loved. Nothing makes sense in terms of consolidating power, all while former Queen Helaena Targaryen (Phia Saban) wastes away, having refused to eat since her mother left. 

While Helaena refuses to eat, her vision remains sharp. She sees a vision of ash consuming her and the farm she is on. She’s taken back to her quarters, and Rhaenyra comes to her. The disconnected way that Emma D’Arcy delivers Rhaenyra’s lines of concern is cold and hollow. Thanks to D’Arcy’s performance, we can see the lie underneath every word she says. 

And, for once, Helaena is given the spotlight to be herself. Here is a woman who knows more than the world around her. As they talk, Helaena mentions a small but beautiful bug that she sees when outside. To which her sister responds that she should show her. But Helaena’s fragility does not mean that she is dumb. Instead of acquiescing in the conversation, she pushes back on the Queen. 

Helaena says that Rhaenyra is lying because everything her sister loves is ugly. Rhaenyra is ugly; KinRhaenyra touches is ugly. And with that comes another refusal to eat and Rhaenyra’s refusal to hide any speck of kindness, as she orders the guards to force-feed Helaena. 

Thanks to the season’s bloated narrative, we find ourselves then taken to Harrenhal. Prince Aemond Targaryen (Ewan Mitchell) is being cared for by Alys Rivers (Gayle Rankin) again. Alicent (Olivia Cooke) poisoned him, and Alys has nursed him back to health yet again. Alys’ commitment to Aemond and her hope not to be alone again are something that needs more exploration. Alys is alone, and Aemond is too.  But Aemond is a kinslayer; his own mother poisoned him, and yet, Alys isn’t pushed away by any of it. 

Instead, she tells Aemond a small story about the last of Harren’s line. The mother who turned to the old ways to save her son. How magic of any kind could not cure dragonfire, and how the woman, in her grief, was cursed, stripped of her name and her castle. For a century, the woman was left to serve every lord who came to Harenhal. And it’s not a surprise that witch Alys Rivers is her. She is the grieving mother. And now, she doesn’t want to be alone; she wants Aemond. 

There is something that bonds the two that goes beyond the relationship we showed her forge with Daemon. The hundred-year-old grieving mother may want to save the man with mommy issues, but it also feels like something deeper. The Aemond we see in Harrenhal is a changed man, and that can’t be understated. 

Harrenhal is grounds for fruitful storytelling, but House of the Dragon Season 3 wastes it.

This works more as an aside that speaks to the magic of the series than it pertains to House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 and, ultimately, feels out of place. With so little time spent with Aemond and Alys, the emotional weight of the scene lands on an audience that hasn’t been primed to accept it. It is just something that happens. 

Too often House of the Dragon has left the magic of Harrenhal unexplored and unexplained. While we finally get answers in “The Treasons at Tumbleton,” we also get little to no closure on a story that could have been left out without much impact. At the very least, until the end of the season’s climactic battle.  

Aemond has so little impact on this season that his emotional ties to Alys Rivers and his acceptance of his own isolation ring hollow. Instead of earning a place in the show, their entire storyline winds up feeling like an afterthought at best and, at worst, a narrative element that had to be added to the series, contributing to its ever-growing bloat problem. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 also pulls into perspective how many characters have been thrown to the wayside. Chief among them is Alyn of Hull. Despite a wonderful performance and heavy emotional moments, Alyn has been reduced to little more than the Queen’s lapdog.

This is something that his brother, Addam, points out when he tries to convince him to go to Tumbleton to save their father. Instead, the Driftmark soldiers and Alyn will accompany Rhaenyra to the Sept to demand that she take the throne, with the Seven’s blessing.

As they make their way to the Sept, we see Rhaenyra differently than we usually do. Her hair is covered by chainmail, her clothes are red and black, her dress is simple and armored. The gender performance is on display as she enters the Sept, confronting a Maester who denies her claim to the throne just for being a woman. 

When she enters, she is denied again, and in her anger she orders Alyn to kill him. It’s a moment where any semblance of honor toward tradition is killed. Rhaenyra was prophesied; Rhaenyra will have her power, no matter who she damns in the process. Still, it’s Alyn who has to carry her sin. It’s Alyn who has to pay for the weight of power that Rhaenyra wants to carry. And he deserved more exploration in that moment, but instead, it’s buried under the weight of a large battle. 

Alyn of Hull is a faithful servant to his queen, even if it damns him. 

In Tumbleton, however, before the fight, Ser Gwayne Hightower (Freddie Fox) and Daeron stand on one of Tumbleton’s walls, looking at the army that comes to them. They are to face the incoming army bravely and pointlessly, as Ser Gwayne explains to his nephew. Where Daeron looks at everything trying to figure it out, Ser Gwayne has accepted his death. He’s accepted the stupidity of the situation they are in and his powerlessness to stop it. 

As the two doubt Ormund, he continues to move without fear of defeat. He is a man who will never admit that he is wrong, that he is fighting a losing battle. Ormund believes he can win, and he does so with cruelty. Ordering children to the front of the battlements for Hightower soldiers to hide behind, the pathetic nature of every choice in this civil war is on full display. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8, however, continues the season’s theme of everything always going bad. As Ormund readies on the walls, Ulf has not shown up. He isn’t with his dragon, and he isn’t on the wall. It’s the first domino in the chaos that is Tumbleton. 

Still, there is one person with honor on that wall. Daeron asserts that he should be on his dragon, that he should fight. There is something inside him that can’t stand by while others die for him, and that, in a way, makes him easily the most fit to rule. As selfishness and power plays have stripped honor from damn near every character in this series, Daeron stands. For him, he fights, or he flees. 

As the Rivermen and the Winter Wolves wait at the Tumbleton gates, Daemon arrives on the back of his dragon. There will be fire and blood, and as the Targaryen colors in King’s Landing switch from black to red, the audience knows exactly what will happen. Despite trying to avoid burning Tumbleton and the people inside of it, we’ve ended up here either way.

With Ormund not in control of his King nephew or Gwayne, and with Ulf nowhere to be found, his refusal to admit mistakes or the possibility of defeat leads Daeron and Gwayne to find a third option. Fight, flee, or choose to trade. Having taken Lord Corlys Velaryon from holding, who, in his own right, refused to trade his honor for coin, they come to Daemon and hope for the best. 

Ser Gwayne, Prince Daeron, and Lord Corlys offer audiences a look at honor, even if just for a second.

What comes next is, for the most part, a negotiation. Ser Gwayne, from behind Lord Corlys, asks Daemon to reach peace by allowing Daeron to rule from Old Town, while Rhaenyra rules in King’s Landing. It’s a split ruling that Rhaenyra herself suggested years ago. But for Daemon, the war ends when every threat is killed. 

Still, Corlys’ intelligence in the situation is clear; he attempts to bring peace. But his deal is different than Ser Gwayne’s. Tie the families together again, wed Daeron to Rhaena (Phoebe Campbell), and use him as leverage to win over the people in the Realm who will not bend the knee to a woman, all while still controlling the outcomes.

As Corlys says, this is an alliance, and Aegon and Aemond will be their common enemy. However, the news of Aegon’s survival and his dragon is news to Ser Gwayne. It’s clear that the Targaryens’ civil war is too filled with rage to come to anything but violence at Tumbleton, but it isn’t for lack of trying from the last honorable men in the ensemble, Gwayne, Daeron, and of course Corlys. 

Daemon believes that Corlys is treasonous, and ultimately his anger is too great to make peace. With his dragon sitting in the back, his men ready to fight, he sends Gwayne back and treats Corlys as his prisoner. What is astounding in this moment is his dedication on display for his wife: “No one will rule over Rhaenyra,” he says, as both a threat and a promise. 

In Harrenhal, there is one more person who wants to rule over the Targaryen Queen, Aegon. While Aemond can never quite tell if something is real or not, Aegon comes to see him. Not realizing it’s really his brother, Aemond is confused at first. But when Aegon lands a slap across his face, he knows it. Aegon has flown to Harrenhal on Sunfyre with every intent on heading to Tumbleton and then King’s Landing. 

Still, that plan is supposed to be completed with Aemond, and not the one that has been haunted in Harrenhal. When Aegon slaps his brother, there is no reaction, only a sad look of guilt.

Throughout his time there, Aemond has moved from angry prince to sad child. He feels regret, and as a repentant man, he has no ire for his older brother hitting him. But to Aegon, this isn’t fun. And that’s when Alys Rivers makes her appearance, introduced as Aemond’s betrothed. 

Outside of Tumbleton, the real meat of the episode takes place. Daemon is giving his orders to his people. The Winter Wolves are the first line; he is at the center, and Lord Oscar Tully (Archie Barnes) is at the flank. It’s here where they learn that Ormund Hightower has lined the battlements with children. In the moment, the table is filled with disgust at Ormund’s cowardice, but they move ahead. 

The Hightowers are baiting Daemon into making Rhaenyra into a monster in House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8. Still, “Take every care to preserve the town and its people” is Daemon’s first request, but it’s also the first thing that is abandoned once the siege starts. 

“The Treasons at Tumbleton” is defined by what happens in the walls. In Daeron and Gwayne not trusting Ormund and seeking out a treaty instead. In Ulf taking up arms against the queen who gave him his dragon (although that doesn’t come until the end, thanks to a day at the tavern). Roderick Stark (Tommy Flanagan) was to lead his Wolves over the wall to save the children. 

Instead, the crazed bannermen of House Stark showcase the power and untamed strength of the North that we have only ever heard about before now. There is still a semblance of keeping the heart of the Realm in mind, to keep Rhaenyra from becoming a tyrant, up until the blood starts to flow. Once violence begins and honor is smothered, everything is lost. 

Rhaenyra the Cruel has entered the chat, and the Sept. 

With Tumbleton under siege, the stakes are at the highest they have been for any of the characters. Back in King’s Landing, Rhaenyra delivers a speech after killing the High Septon.

In Old Valyrian, she shouts, “I am the prince that was promised,” accenting her recounting of the prophecy her father told her, and that he was passed down when he took the Iron Throne, and so on. She is the only person who can light the way to save the realm from the winter threats beyond the Wall. 

It’s a panicked yet angry rebuttal to those who would wish her ill or denounce her rule. To her, she is the only hope for humanity; she is the rightful heir, and she will be the King that was promised.

It’s a moment that reshapes the lens through which we view her; it’s a moment of ascension by any means, and one carried out with her family’s bodies and those who trust her at her feet. This is no better shown than by a silent Mysaria in the crowd. 

As the battle begins, it’s the Winter Wolves who drum loudly on their shields, as children cower behind the battlements, shaking with fear. And the primal way that the Wolves celebrate their own deaths and the storming of the battlements lets the audience know what is about to happen to Tumbleton. When Stark kills a child knowingly, the future of this city is easy to predict; there is none. 

The Hightowers, on the other hand, are trying to scrape their plan up off the floor. Ulf is nowhere to be found, and Daemon is knocking on the door as the Stark bannermen begin to make their way down. But with the gate still locked, Daemon uses Caraxes to open the gate. 

But it’s not just the gate that Daemon is burning; it’s children too. In a last-ditch effort to buy time, Ormund sends the remaining children out to the front of the gate to stand in the way. While Daemon orders them to move, there is nowhere for them to move. He says “dracarys” anyway. 

“The Treasons at Tumbleton” show characters crossing lines they can’t come back from.

There is no honor to be appealed to in “The Treasons at Tumbleton.” There are no great knights abiding by their oaths, and no great hero to stop the carnage. Just fire and blood, and fear. Rhaenyra’s reign will now forever be connected to the slaughtering of children, as if it wasn’t already, and there is no coming back from it. It is war. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 isn’t just a sacking of a city, though. As Rhaenyra’s forces crash into Tumbleton, Ulf is finally found, passed out in his own filth.  After Ormund briefly beats him, he takes to the skies. First met with cheers, the horror begins when he lights their entire forces on fire. From then on, it’s chaos, with small character moments woven into the battle. 

On the surface, the battle at Tumbleton is some of the finest action work in the series. Matched with Episode 1’s naval combat, the series is at its strongest when it goes all in on the fighting. But the spectacle that these eight episodes have reached for doesn’t make up for the character work it has lost. 

As Ulf brings fire down on everyone, he kills soldiers. Daemon kills children. There are lines crossed in this battle that can’t be undone. Additionally, while Ulf deserts Rhaenyra’s call, so has Hugh the Hammer (Kieran Bew). Mostly nonexistent in House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8, he does make his way to the city to save his wife. Only, she’s gone. Killed by Winter Wolves, and not the Hightower soldiers.

There is nothing here for anyone anymore, and it seems that every character knows it. But the race to the bottom results in prolonged tragedy that no great scale of battle can undo. As the siege spirals out of control, it’s clear that no great house has anything in order. Ulf is ordered to do as he was told, but here there is resentment as the entirety of Tumbleton is burned to bits. 

Somehow, Corlys survives; Daemon battles a soldier who calls him “Kingslayer,” and almost loses;  Stark loses an arm but kills Ormund, leaving him with an extremely pathetic death only before Ulf consumes them both in dragonfire. There is nothing but woe here. 

Too much spectacle and not enough emotional resonance is House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8’s problem.

In the battle, Daeron emerges as maybe the realm’s last honorable man, looking to take to the skies with his dragon to help. He wants to be someone who isn’t a coward. He doesn’t know what to do, but death may be his only dignity with all that he has seen Ormund do in his name. “I won’t be remembered a craven,” he asserts, but Tumbleton is lost either way. 

Emerging from the battle, of those in the city, we only know that Ser Gwayne, Corlys, Daemon, Hugh, and Ulf are alive. There is nothing but ash and ruin. Shown from Daemon’s perspective on the ground, the audience sees everything. The burned bodies of women, children, and men. People without families, soldiers doing their worst regardless of who they meet. A somber score backs Daemon’s last push in Tumbleton before Corlys pulls him out. 

It is the weakest we have ever seen Daemon as well. Shaken, his eyes are large, and the reality that he almost died is sinking in too. There is almost nothing left to fight for, but the vanity of kings, and the only people who lie in the rubble are those with no power to change a single thing.

There is nothing of Tumbleton left. What Rhaenyra wanted to avoid has come to pass, and now she doesn’t care. Matt Smith’s performance as Daemon Targaryen this season has been more vulnerable than we’ve seen. He’s come a long way in terms of dealing with transgressions. And at the same time, the look he has when Corlys turns him around leaves a lasting impact on the devastation of this battle. 

There are sights he can not unsee. He almost lost his fight with Ormund’s right hand, and he doomed a group of children to dragonfire. There is no way to rehabilitate Rhaenyra now, but as she embraces the crown and the people of Tumbleton are dead or homeless, we know that she will not care. 

And that apathy toward everything but her own power is also on display back in King’s Landing; Heleana has jumped from her balcony, leaving her tapestry of dreams behind. Rhaenyra’s bargaining chips, like the Hightowers, are gone now.

There is no power but the dragons, whose indiscriminate fire has smashed through people and cities. There is nothing to hold onto when it comes to hope, and now all sides can only hold onto the lie that one day the power will satiate them. 

Rheanyra Targaryen is ruling over rubble in Tumbleton, and it’s only going to be the beginning. 

In “The Treasons at Tumbleton,” there are no happy endings, but that is not the season’s problem. A tragedy that stretches across eight hours of television leaves the audience exhausted alongside the characters. Not with their pain, but with their folly. Every character is flailing, and in doing so, they distract from the larger emotional beats that should be taking the spotlight throughout the story. 

Gender, lineage, legacy, motherhood, love, rage, and above all else, power are all themes that House of the Dragon has attempted to explore. Only, with every season, the series pulls itself farther from an earnest investigation of any of them. 

When Hugh finds his wife dead in her home, we should feel something. When Helaena dies, we should feel that loss in that story, rather than a whimper gone by. Alyn’s damnation by his god at the hand of his queen shouldn’t be brought up only to be discarded. And most specifically, Harrenhal’s space in this tale deserves more than to be the scenes that bear no weight on anything else. 

There is no dearth of big emotional moments in the House of the Dragon Season 3 finale, but there is a lack of earnest focus that would give those pieces of story something to cling to. We do not need another story where every character is likable, but we do need a story where the conscious choices they make have ramifications that aren’t built up only to be glazed over for something more dramatic. 

In a vacuum, House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 is good, maybe even a great one. But when laid against the seven others before it, it’s a culmination of the season’s missteps. The big moments feel unearned or bogged down by how little we know about them. The deaths feel empty, and the conclusion is asking us to look to the future for more answers. The reality is that this episode needed to come sooner in the season, rather than serving as the perfect end piece after a bloated buildup. 

While Rhaenyra looks at Helaena’s complete tapestry, she sees herself holding a sword and covered in blood. It’s the last answer to her questions. A Queen at the top, with fire and blood consuming the rest of the image. Rhaenyra has finally reached the point in her rule that was foreshadowed when Jace died. The only problem is how long we took to get there. 

House of the Dragon Season 3 Episode 8 is more frustrating than it is bad. It reminds the viewer of just how long this one battle has been brewing, drops in character moments that have no weight in the current circumstances, and ignores others who see a small piece of the spotlight this episode. If the series could get out of its own way and stop trying to drag on when it should be concise, it would thrive. House of the Dragon has everything it needs to succeed; it just needs a better editor.

House of the Dragon Season 3 is streaming now on HBO MAX. 

Previous Episode |

Season 1 Review | Season 2 Review | Season 3 Review